• June 27, 2022
 How can Texas fix its marijuana problem after legalizing hemp? Forensic experts have a plan.

Getty Images/iStockphoto

How can Texas fix its marijuana problem after legalizing hemp? Forensic experts have a plan.

The scientists think they’ve come up with a solution to Texas’ pot problem.

Forensic and crime lab experts are optimistic state and local officials will support a new proposal that would allow for a faster, cheaper way to test suspected marijuana under the state’s new definition of the drug.

But even if law enforcement and crime labs agree to move forward with the proposal, it would still be months before labs could start testing cases for prosecutors. And there are still some looming questions — like who would pay for the additional crime lab resources?

Last month, when Gov. Greg Abbott signed into law a bill to legalize hemp and hemp-derived products, like CBD oil, the legal definition of marijuana changed from cannabis to cannabis that contains more than 0.3% of tetrahydrocannabinol, or THC, the psychoactive ingredient in marijuana. Cannabis below that level is now legal hemp.

The sudden change created chaos for Texas prosecutors handling marijuana charges under the new law. Most district attorneys in the state’s 10 most populous counties, including both Democrats and Republicans, have said testing THC levels is now required to prosecute low-level marijuana cases, since a defendant’s claim that a substance is hemp would cast too much reasonable doubt over criminal proceedings without it. The problem is the public labs in Texas don’t have equipment or a process to quantify THC concentration.

Numerous district attorneys have dropped cases and refused to accept new charges without further testing. Others have paused cases while they figure out how to proceed, and some have said they will continue to prosecute marijuana cases, with at least one saying test results aren’t usually needed.

In a letter Thursday, Abbott and other state leaders argued that cases could still be handled with the “tried-and-true” use of circumstantial evidence. Top prosecutors and lab experts have argued against this, saying things like the smell of marijuana are no longer credible evidence since hemp and marijuana come from the same plant.

Initially, crime labs said testing equipment would cost up to $500,000 per machine. One lab director estimated more than 20 labs would need the equipment to cover the state caseload. And even after they got those machines, the labs would have needed to go through an accreditation process that could take a year or more before they could test samples for law enforcement.

Now, after meeting last week with officials from the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency, which worked to distinguish hemp from marijuana when the U.S. farm bill legalized hemp in 2018 on the federal level, the Texas Forensic Science Commission’s general counsel said local officials are looking to use the same approach.

“For six months, [the DEA] figured out what they needed to do in order to provide the best, most taxpayer-efficient, economical way of distinguishing between hemp and marijuana,” Lynn Garcia told The Texas Tribune.

The federal agency’s approach is to do an initial series of tests that indicate if a substance has above or below a 1% THC concentration. Although the method looks for a concentration that is slightly higher than the legal cutoff, Garcia said the test will likely satisfy most law enforcement needs, adding that nearly all marijuana prosecutions involve THC concentrations of 12% or higher. Things like vape pen oil rise far beyond that.

The most appealing part of this plan: Texas labs already have the equipment needed to perform these tests, cutting expected costs and implementation time.

“It’s able to give law enforcement what they need to make decisions at the front end using a much less expensive process than I think what our labs were thinking they were going to have to do,” Garcia said.

But the price tag and wait time wouldn’t drop to zero. Adding a large new caseload of suspected marijuana samples to already backlogged crime labs would still create a need for more employees and equipment, said Peter Stout, president of the Houston Forensic Science Center, which manages the city’s crime lab.

“The challenge that we’re going to have is we’re talking tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of tests across the state,” he said. “We probably don’t have enough equipment.”

Garcia said the machines in place now would also likely need to be replaced more often with this type of testing. Still, she expects a need for fewer new instruments at the onset, and these machines cost significantly less — about $75,000 each.

The tests the DEA uses would also take much less time, about an hour as opposed to two days, putting less of an additional strain on the crime labs, Garcia said.

A spokesperson for the Texas District and County Attorney’s Association, which alerted prosecutors last month that pursuing marijuana cases had suddenly become more difficult, said the approach would be a viable solution to the problems caused by the new legislation.

But Stout said it will probably still take a couple of weeks before a final plan of action is agreed upon among stakeholders, including law enforcement and forensic experts. And although it seems likely the labs would be able to bypass any accreditation process using the proposed method since they already use this equipment for other tests, they would still need to validate the DEA’s methods. The plan would be for The Texas Department of Public Safety, which runs 13 state crime labs, and local labs to work with Sam Houston State University to ensure the DEA testing works in Texas.

“I have to be able to demonstrate it’s going to do what I think it’s going to do before we start doing casework,” Stout said.

Both Stout and Sarah Kerrigan, chair of the forensic science department at Sam Houston State University, said that process will still take months. Meanwhile, many Texas counties will hold marijuana cases in limbo or refuse to accept them.

Still, it’s a step in the right direction, they say.

“The solution is much more readily available,” Kerrigan said. “It’s still going to take some time, but it’s not going to be as logistically complex.”

Despite the apparent agreement among experts on a plan of action, one lingering question remains unanswered: Who is going to pay for the crime labs’ costs of the new legislation? The hemp bill was passed without any dedicated funds attached to it.

Over the next two years, the Legislature will funnel about $50 million into the DPS crime labs to help with chronic backlogs, but a spokesperson for the Houston Forensic Science Center said that money is because DPS is already crushed — this testing will require new resources. Garcia said she hopes DPS will get them. DPS officials did not respond to questions for this story.

“A lot of the labs are already struggling,” said Kerrigan. “Controlled substances is already the most backlogged discipline, so they don’t always have the human resources to get something done.”

Abbott did not respond to repeated requests for comment about funding for new testing under the law, though his letter to prosecutors noted that testing costs would be much less than originally expected.

Disclosure: Sam Houston State University has been a financial supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune’s journalism. Find a complete list of them here.

Author: JOLIE MCCULLOUGH  – The Texas Tribune

Read related Tribune coverage

The Texas Tribune


The Texas Tribune is a nonpartisan, nonprofit media organization that informs Texans — and engages with them – about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues. Facebook (@TexasTribune) Twitter (@TexasTribune) Instagram (@Texas_Tribune)

Related post


  • The real problem with Texas is that Texas is a damn oppressive rebel republican state! I still remember when we had those Sunday Texas Blue Laws! That was some ridiculous stuff, and that was during democratic legislation times.
    Now it’s become way worst, we have complete takeover of Texas by republicans, and some democrats that love to kiss their ass holes. Why do other states offer their citizens the right to smoke marijuana either for medicinal or recreational use.
    But not here in the state of Texas! where Law Enforcement gets their hard on’s by arresting and busting innocent none violent pot smokers. The whole process is to ruin their lives and their reputations, and line their pockets with tons of cash.
    That is how they make their livings, is to be complete ass holes, not to mention the private prison industry thrives with marijuana bust and incarceration. Court cost,lawyers charges,detention cost,parole and probation officers, all make money off marijuana. Why don’t they get real jobs instead? Get a LIFE ass holes!
    We have this ruthless governor Gregg Abbott, he don’t give a damn about legalizing marijuana, he’s a bitter ass hole because he had a jogging incident where a tree branch broke off the tree. And landed on him making him a paraplegic for life! That incident was an Act of God! nobody leaves this world without paying their dues, and Gregg Abbott is NO EXCEPTION! He’s done some bad things in his life before and he has still not repented! so instead he gets worst.As he takes his pain out on others for his own personal problems.
    But Texas, We are better than that! it’s time to get off their High Horses and legalize marijuana, think of all the state revenue marijuana could make for our state! For state infrastructure, roads,schools,hire more cops and firemen and school teachers etc.
    Marijuana got a bad rap during the propaganda reefer madness lies of the past! the chemical industry,the tobacco and alcohol industry. They all don’t want marijuana to become legal.
    Legalizing marijuana would cause them to lose revenue.
    On the other hand, look at tobacco? it gets you addicted,then eventually kills you with all sorts of diseases like cancer. Same with alcohol, yet they both are legal, at least marijuana don’t destroy you,you don’t get addicted, and no one has ever overdose from smoking it.
    It’s at our discretion on how to use it in a responsible way! and the only bad thing about it,is if you are using it with drugs or alcohol, that’s a bad mix,then you are on your own, for being stupid.
    Like alcohol, it can distract you,especially if you are driving, so it’s always better to smoke in the privacy of your own home.
    But it’s still illegal to smoke it here in Texas,because Gregg Abbott has a bad vendetta about it! and so do many other ass holes that are prejudice about it. Look what the opioid abuse is doing to Texans? it’s a point of no return.The pharmaceuticals are raking in BIG BUCKS! and yet they want marijuana to remain illegal.
    Hemp is good for farmers and marijuana is good for freedom thinking human beings.
    Only the prejudice ignorant’s think otherwise! they all want to control our minds like those over at Fox News!
    I always get accused of smoking it! but I know better, not to break Texas state laws, so I wait till maybe someday,it will become legalize here in Texas. But I’m not going to hold my breath waiting for it to become a reality. There’s another form of getting high, and it’s legal, it’s called HIGH ON LIFE! meaning that I can see right through my critics and make fun of them. And yet they don’t know where I’m coming from due to their paranoia and ignorant moronic stupidity.

    • Is the doper scum Alberto triggered?

      • Why does Mad Mike suck so much ass hole? he’s definitely triggered up his ass hole.

  • Dumbass pothead Alberto will soon be ranting in. Can’t keep his big fat mouth shut. lmao.

    • Fero follows me around like a barking puppy! he stayed up all night to see if I would start posting comments on the KKKVIA forum.
      2:30 am came and went, so he waited and waited and waited some more till 8:17 am, he went over to the El Paso Herald Post,to again look to see if I had dropped by.
      Fero is not good for words and he can’t remember what he did yesterday,because I happen to live rent free inside Fero’s hollow section 8 skull.
      On another marijuana topic, Fero said that he does beat up five year old boys and girls! or below.
      But went on to say that I couldn’t beat a five year old up! well at least I don’t pick fights with toddlers!
      But Fero does pick fights with toddlers, besides putting them into chokes holes and doing the unthinkable naughty nasty things he does best. Other than doing what Donald trump does to women!
      He gropes toddlers like those at the TSA airport security.
      take that and smoke it inside your crack pipe! HA HA HA HA HA! PRICELESS!!!! ANOTHER BEAT TO the poor marano la fero!
      TRUMP IS GOING TO PRISON and JefFero Epstein will be there in time, just keep trump’s prison bed warm Jeffero! the fat orange daddy’s coming home to you soon.

Comments are closed.