window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);} gtag('js', new Date()); gtag('config', 'UA-29484371-30');
Monday , October 22 2018
JustLikeThat728
SUNLANDPARK 728X90
728×90 pluck b
TESTIFY 728X90
Home | Opinion | Op-Ed: Propaganda

Op-Ed: Propaganda

When I was in 7th grade or thereabouts, I remember Mrs. Aunie allowing some of us that finished our work early to play a game called “Propaganda.”

Each player was given an example type of propaganda, be it political, advertising, whatever. The other players had to try to figure out which one, out of over 50 types, of propaganda technique was being used. It was a great game, because it taught the players ways to detect when they were being mentally manipulated by advertisers, religious leaders, politicians, military leaders, even your friends.

It was my true first view that the world I experienced wasn’t exactly the way I was experiencing it. That doctor in the commercial that recommended we eat Grape Nuts may not actually be a doctor?

That statistic that showed 4 out 5 dentists recommended sugarless gum might have been manipulated? That politician that said “…the American people want so and so” might just be using some skewed poll?

When Oil Of Olay made you look 10 years younger, what happened if you were 8 years old and put it on? When the President asked God to “Bless America,” what about all of the other countries? (Check out the 50 types of propaganda here)

I thought about the Propaganda Game while watching the O’Rourke/ Cruz debate.

Ted Cruz pointed across the stage at Beto O’Rourke and said that “his are not the values of Texans.” A few in the crowd cheered. The implication of course, was that his opponent, Beto O”Rourke was some kind of stranger to Texas, an elitist, a carpetbagger, trying to come in and take away your “Texas approved” whatever.

Never mind that O’Rourke was born and raised in Texas. It was a classic propaganda technique: use a vague phrase with little or no meaning. By doing so, the audience had to mentally fill in the blanks. Hmm, Texas Values. He doesn’t have them, whatever they are. I have Texas values I am sure of it. He doesn’t. That must be bad.

Of course, phrases like “Texas Values” and its corollary “American Values” sound good and important, but actually mean little. What exactly is a “Texas value?” We could rattle off some weird list, like “guns, god, bar-b-q and family” but even those are vague.

Do your “Texas values” match the values of your neighbor? How about your in-laws? Do black Texans have the same “values” as hispanic or white Texans? Do Dallas and Houston billionaires have the same set of values that the people living in border city “colonias” have? Do women have the same values as men?

I suspect in a state with 28 million people, there are probably close to 28 million sets of “Texas values.”

The phrase “Texas Values” is pure political propaganda, with little or no meaning. In fact, the entire debate was filled with propaganda techniques, taken right from the list above. You could sit down and play “Propaganda Bingo” during the debate: Appeal to prejudice, non sequiturs, faulty analogies, vagueness, and on and on.

It was an orgy of the 50 propaganda techniques above.

Unfortunately, not many of our students, nay I say adults, are aware that they are being manipulated every day by propaganda. Does that basketball player, a person that measures every single thing that goes into his body to maximize performance, really drink Sprite and eat Slim Jims?

Does that politician really know what “Texas Values” are? Do four-out-of-five dentists really recommend sugarless gum? Does that makeup with Retinol V Moisturizing Formula really eliminate wrinkles, or does it just fill in cracks like so much spackling paste on drywall?

Were the founders of Texas really heroes? Go to any website with advertising and you are being manipulated by propaganda. Watch any news show and the same is happening.

Go ahead and watch Fox News for 60 minutes with the list of propaganda techniques listed above. I bet you get at least half of them checked off in less than an hour.

Maybe everyone should play the Propaganda Game like I and my fellow Crosby Cougars did all those years ago in Ms. Aunie’s 7th grade Social Studies class.

And you can! The game, created all those years ago by Bonanza star Lorne Greene is still alive online. It’s free. It’s educational.

And it might just make you and your kids see things in an entirely new light.

***

Author: Tim Holt is an educator and writer, with over 33 years experience in education and opines on education-related topics here and on his own award-winning blog: HoltThink. He values your feedback.

Feel free to leave a comment.  Read his previous columns here.

About Tim Holt

Tim Holt is an educator and writer, with over 33 years experience in education and opines on education-related topics here and on his own award-winning blog: HoltThink. He values your feedback.

Check Also

Tim Holt’s 10 Questions: Rewiring Education

John Couch is a former (and FIRST) Apple VP of Education and has written, along …

7 comments

  1. Another totally partisan opinion piece

  2. Hi Mikey
    Thanks again for carefully reading my column. Faithful readers can count on you for your weekly insightful comments.

    I look forward to your well thought out rebuttal which I am sure the Herald Post will gladly publish.

  3. Exactly! We have been conditioned and conditioned and conditioned. A politician waves the flag, a bible or spouts the “American Way verbiage” and too many fall for this over and over and over. Slap a flag, a cross or use the accepted phrase and you can make people believe anything! It’s all about packaging!

    • Andy,
      Thank you for reading my column. Perhaps we need to add identifying propaganda to our student’s curriculum. (Although I bet the politicians wouldn’t like that too much!)

  4. Vote Blue this November

    America saw propaganda used by the Republicans in the Kavanaugh farce hearings. It is everywhere as you point out and I think we should teach school children to recognize it.

    • Vote Blue…The problem is how do we teach what we do not know? What you are saying about the Republicans and the Kavanaugh hearings is exactly what the Republicans are saying about the Democrats and the Kavanaugh hearings. Both sides can make a case for the use of propaganda by the other side. Whos’ telling the truth? No one really knows. Who’s right? The real losers in all of this is Dr. Ford, Judge Kavanaugh and ultimately America.

      Teaching this in school won’t help. It’s become to much of a political bloodbath. There’s no turning back now. Both sides are in too deep trying to save themselves. Plus, it would only be taught from one side.

      Even the author of this article, which I mostly agree with (that’s a first for me), is using a few forms of propaganda in his story about teaching people how to detect propaganda. There’s some irony for you. Even though he acknowledges the fact the debate was full of propaganda he only gives specifics about how Cruz used propaganda but conveniently leaves out the forms and examples of propaganda that O’Rourke utilized. A clear propaganda strategy on Tim’s part. ” True to form” wouldn’t you say Tim?

      • Dear MAGA,
        Thank you for reading my column. I would venture to say that any opinion piece, by definition, uses the various techniques of propaganda to get the point across. That doesn’t make the point less valid.

TESTIFY 728X90
JustLikeThat728
728×90 pluck b
SUNLANDPARK 728X90