window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);} gtag('js', new Date()); gtag('config', 'UA-29484371-30');
Tuesday , March 19 2019
Bordertown Undergroun Show 728
shark 728×90
Utep_DEC_728
EPHP Spring Training
Amy’s Ambassadorship
JustLikeThat728
STEP 728
Home | Opinion | Op-Ed: Teaching Bible Literacy in Public Schools is a Terrible Idea

Op-Ed: Teaching Bible Literacy in Public Schools is a Terrible Idea

Recently, after getting his daily national security briefing from the trioka of talking heads on “Fox and Friends,” which horse-whispered to him “at least six states…have introduced legislation this year pushing for public schools to offer Bible literacy classes” our president tweeted out the following message:

“Numerous states introducing Bible Literacy classes, giving students the option of studying the Bible. Starting to make a turn back? Great!”

Great.

 

 

 

 

 

Putting aside the incredible irony of a lying, possibly traitorous, misogynistic, tax evading, adultering billionaire suggesting that the teachings of the Bible are a good thing to be followed, this idea, like many he tweets from the warm confines of the Presidential residence during his special “Executive Time” is an incredibly bad idea.

One could make the case that he is just playing to his base of red hatted evangelical sycophants and grovelers who simply refuse to see that their emperor wears no clothes.

Or one could make the case that he is trying to really MAGA to those days in the good ol’ US-of-A when everyone was literate about the Bible and all it stood for when homebound moms vacuumed the house while wearing pearls and a dress, eagerly awaiting dads to return from a hard days work of slapping the secretaries’ behind, where every child was above average and America was a Mad Men fantasy land.

Oh, and every family was very white and went to church every Sunday. You ‘member, don’t you?

Fact is, that America never existed, except in the minds of Hollywood writers and Madison Avenue ad executives. Yet that America, that fiction, is one of the driving forces behind the recent movement about the return of “bible literacy,“ to get Jesus back into classrooms, where in fact, he was never banned except in the minds of evangelical snowflakes.

Who is behind this push you might ask? Is it an altruistic movement bent on improving ethics and civility in today’s youth? Educators who know the needs of students? Parents clamoring for a return to the good old days? No, it is politics. And right winged politics at that. Ever heard of Project Blitz, the Congressional Prayer Caucus Foundation, the National Legal Foundation or the WallBuilders ProFamily Legislative Network? They are the ones behind the push to get bible literacy in front of your kid. Notice Jesus is nowhere on that list.

There are multiple states that offer some kind of Bible literacy classes in High School. (Some states have offered Bible literacy classes since the beginning of public schools, as being able to read the Bible was one of the original reasons to teach reading in Puritanical days.) However, many of these current courses are shrouded in the factually inaccurate idea that only the Hebrew and Christian bibles were the basis for many of the ideas of how our country was founded. Never mind that Jefferson said:

“That our civil rights have no dependance on our religious opinions, any more than on our opinions in physicks or geometry. … We the General Assembly of Virginia do enact, that no man shall be compelled to frequent or support any relig[i]ous Worship, place or Ministry whatsoever, nor shall be enforced, restrained, molested, or burthened in his body or goods, nor shall otherwise suffer on account of his religious opinions or belief, but that all men shall be free to profess, and by argument to maintain their opinions in matters of religion, and that the same shall in no wise diminish, enlarge, or affect their civil capacities.”

What did Jefferson know anyway? He just wrote the Constitution.

But heck, we live in Texas where the Social Studies standards falsely claim that Moses was a major influence on the Constitution and the roots of our nation’s political systems are found in the Bible. So in Texas, high school students can sign up to take:

  • Independent Study in English: Hebrew Scriptures
  • Independent Study in English: New Testament
  • Independent Study in English: Hebrew Scriptures and New Testament
  • Special Topics in Social Studies: Hebrew Scripture (Old Testament)
  • Special Topics in Social Studies: New Testament
  • Special Topics in Social Studies: Hebrew Scriptures and New Testament

Notice anything about these courses? Hmm, could there be a slight slant to the point of view that students are exposed to? America is a vast country with many point of views, ranging from fanatics to non-believers. Courses like these should not be limited to a single religious perspective. Yet, there you are.

And even though these are largely courses that are offered as electives and count only for local credit, what happens in small rural districts where a lot of students could take these courses and one or two don’t?

“What’s wrong with Crystal? She isn’t taking Bible Literacy like all the rest of us! She must not love the baby Jesus.” Crystal may be forced to wear the scarlet letter of avoidance. Never mind that Crystal might be Hindu, or Muslim, or her family a member of a denomination that thinks religion should better be left in the confines of a church or even atheists. In small districts, just like at Cheers, everybody knows your name. And your business.

Again pushing aside the irony that the Right does not trust public schools enough to teach sex education or global climate change to their kids, yet they seem to have no problem when it comes to religion, there are many concerns that come up with any type of class in a public school being used to teach the teachings of any specific religious group.

Unlike say, Physics (where Force=Mass X Acceleration no matter the time or place you teach it) or Algebra where the rules for quadratic equations work across the globe, experience with the various denominations of the Christian faith include so many variations of a theme that one would be hard pressed to teach a class on Christian bible literacy without it becoming an act of proselytizing a particular point of view, which, by the way, is at the foundation of the entire religion itself.

Your denomination’s Bible teaches that homosexuality is an abomination to the Lord. Mine doesn’t.

Your’s says women should be subservient to men. Mine doesn’t.

Baptist’s believe that the Bible prohibits drink or dance. The Methodists say “have at it!”

Is the story of Noah’s Ark true, or is it simply a copy of the writings of the stories of Gilgamesh? Who is right? Who is wrong? Who is to judge? Whose bible literacy will we be using? Baptists? Methodists? Catholics? Presbyterians? Snake Handlers? The Reformed Asian Orthodoxy? The Greek Orthodox? The Russian Orthodox? The Needed Truth Brethren? The Messianic Jews? The Pentecostals? The Adventists?

Which Bible version, of the hundreds that are out there, would be used as the definitive one for a class like this? The “official” text? Are we going to teach about the Book of Wisdom from the Catholic version, include the Book of Mormon, or tell kids that their version “doesn’t count?”

Some Christian denominations take the entire Bible literally (six days to make the earth) some metaphorically, some a mixture of both. Denominations cannot even agree on what parts are metaphors and which aren’t. Some cannot even agree on what parts of the Old Testament they should be kept and which shouldn’t.

After 2000 years of study, the debate continues with little or no end in sight, because, frankly, no one group can agree on anything with any other group nor do they really want to. Imagine if we taught any other course that way? Imagine a math teacher trying to explain that 2+2 may or may not equal to 4 depending on where you were born and what your parents believe.

Imagine a teacher trying to teach that Newton’s 3 Laws of Motion may or may not be true depending on what version of text book they are using? Three branches of government? Maybe that’s true, but not in this State, because the legislature believes in only two of them.

Those are the kind of problems that would arise if we taught the Bible literacy.

The Bible as Literature? No problem. The Bible as part of a survey course about world religions? Great. But if you are trying to push your religion down the throats of impressionable teens, stop. Save it for church. Teach ethics in an ethics course.

Teach citizenship in a civics course. Teaching the Bible as a a course unto itself is simply a terrible idea.

How about teaching that?

***

Author: Tim Holt is an educator and writer, with over 33 years experience in education and opines on education-related topics here and on his own award-winning blog: HoltThink. He values your feedback.

Feel free to leave a comment.  Read his previous columns here.

About Tim Holt

Tim Holt is an educator and writer, with over 33 years experience in education and opines on education-related topics here and on his own award-winning blog: HoltThink. He values your feedback.

Check Also

Video: Cornyn Votes to Secure Border, Calls for Reform of National Emergencies Act

WASHINGTON – Thursday on the floor of the Senate, U.S. Senator John Cornyn (R-TX) discussed …

13 comments

  1. Great article. I wonder if these bible classes would include all of the juicy sex parts of the Bible that are left out of the Sunday sermon? Will they learn about the “juice squeezed from my pomegranates” from the Song of Solomon? How will the teacher explain ““You also took the fine jewelry I gave you, the jewelry made of my gold and silver, and you made for yourself male idols and engaged in prostitution with them. )Ezekiel 16:17)? Of course, my favorite for all High School Seniors would be the passage: ““When she carried on her whoring so openly and flaunted her nakedness, I turned in disgust from her, as I had turned in disgust from her sister. Yet she increased her whoring, remembering the days of her youth, when she played the whore in the land of Egypt and lusted after her lovers there, whose members were like those of donkeys, and whose issue was like that of horses. Thus you longed for the lewdness of your youth, when the Egyptians handled your bosom and pressed your young breasts.” (Ezekiel 23:18-21)

    Let the learning begin!

  2. Bibles belong in church. Want to study the bible? Go to Sunday school. Don’t force feed my kid your Bronze Age beliefs. Believe in fariy tales if you must, but keep them to your cult and out of schools. Where is the ACLU in all of this? Arent they fighting this?

    I saw a sign that said “Religion is like a penis: It is nice to have one, but don’t wave it in front of my face.”

  3. God help us...the left certainly won't!

    The new Democratic party:

    Kill babies (either inside or outside of the womb, we don’t care either away!)

    Save the planet but make sure farting cows are put on the extinct species list.

    Eliminate religion. UNLESS it gives the left something that they need!

    Open borders. Open to all (criminals or not, we’ll take them all and even pay for those not willing to work) unless of course you are cattle (those we must eradicate)

    Eliminate GOD. UNLESS making a reference to GOD helps the left’s cause.

    Eliminate all forms of travel but make sure the replacing forms of travel run off of batteries so that we can fill our land fills with millions of spent batteries instead (Brilliant!). Oh wait, it’s oK for the left to destroy the planet because we have a one way system. Left can do no wrong, the right can do no right!

    Congratulations. Your transformation to evil is finally complete. Your hatred for conservatism and for this amazing President has solidified you journey. You made some fairly decent points but since you started your propaganda filled rant by once again bashing our President who is fixing the mess that our former President left behind then I can only view what you have to say as nothing but the BS that it is!

    • Dear God,
      Thank you for carefully reading my piece. I am glad that you found some decent points.
      Tim

    • Perhaps Mr. Holt’s article would have been more effective if Trump wasn’t mentioned (making the article seem less biased); however, mentioning him is appropriate because Trump made the statement regarding Bible Study courses.

      Stating that “his transformation to evil is finally complete” is extremely judgmental coming from a person that is defending the right to teach Bible courses in High Schools. One pressumes that you are a “Christian” based on your comments but your actions are far from Jesus’s teachings!

    • I have Some Xanex if you need it

      Dude, are you off your meds?

    • Jesus Christ IS Our Lord and Savior

      Wow. Just Wow.
      I know that I won’t get an answer because these tidy-righty type people are like pigeons– they come in , crap all over the place, and then go to the next article to crap on without ever explaining themselves, never returning. Then they think they have converted those that dont think like them by doing that.

      But I wonder how this person can come to the conclusion that not teaching a Bible Literacy course would “eliminate God?” That is quite a powerful course indeed!

      What a dufus. If that person is an example of the current right winged in USA…then GOD help us!

      • God help us...the left certainly won't!

        You will get a response. Look at the trends. Religion has slowly taken a back seat to everything the left supports. You now have a clearly anti-Semitic Democratic congresswomen who is publically denouncing Israel. And there will be more. You have democratic states legalizing late-term and POST birth abortions. There have been talks of removing the words “One nation under God” and “In god we trust”. What’s next? I don’t know but there will be something. There is a very slippery slop here. That’s all I’m saying.

        • I have Some Xanex if you need it

          I am taking it that you support teaching the bible in school? Which version do you prefer?

        • Needs a Histroy Class, not a Bible Class

          God Help Us,
          You have heard that little idea that religion and politics should be separated right? Or, like in the Bible, you only take the parts of the Constitution that you agree with, and ignore the rest?

  4. I am all for Bible Courses being offered if they are taught as a “Literature Appreciation” Course. The Bible is “the greatest story ever told.” It is a book full of wonderful stories that rival any fairy tale. The Bible is a book full of fantastic tales that cannot be true!

    I am also for the Bible to be taught in our High Schools if along w/it the Koran and other religious books are also taught. By teaching about different religions we would open students’ perspectives and exposing them to different cultures and hopefully build empathy in then; if these happened, maybe then we could MAGA!

JustLikeThat728
STEP 728
Utep_DEC_728
Amy’s Ambassadorship
shark 728×90
Bordertown Undergroun Show 728
EPHP Spring Training